Job title: Senior Commercial Lines CSR
Job type: Permanent
Emp type: Full-time
Industry: Insurance
Functional Expertise: Account Manager
Location: Mechanicsburg, PA
Job published: 06/02/2026
Job ID: 155396

Job Description

Senior Commercial Lines CSR

Job Summary

Seeking a highly skilled and experienced Senior Commercial Lines Customer Service Representative (CSR) to join a team. This role is ideal for a professional who thrives in a collaborative environment and is passionate about delivering exceptional service to clients. While this is not a leadership role, there is potential for growth into a Team Lead or Commercial Lines Service Manager position for candidates who demonstrate leadership capabilities and a desire to advance.

The ideal candidate will have a strong background in commercial insurance, particularly in servicing churches, non-profits, and faith-based organizations. Experience with Applied Epic is essential, and familiarity with Erie Insurance is a significant advantage. This position offers a hybrid work arrangement, with a preference for candidates located within 45 minutes of the Harrisburg/Mechanicsburg area.

Compensation Package

  • Salary Range: $85,000 - $95,000 annually (flexible up to $100,000 - $105,000 for candidates with Team Lead or Service Manager experience).
  • Benefits:
    • 100% employer-paid health insurance for employees (partial coverage for dependents).
    • 3% IRA match.
    • Paid Time Off (PTO): Starts at 10-11 days, with a maximum of 25 days (negotiable to start at 15-16 days).
  • Additional Perks:
    • Commission opportunities for candidates with a sales component.
    • Hybrid work flexibility (2-3 days in-office preferred).
    • Fully remote option available for exceptional candidates.

Responsibilities

  • Manage and service a book of commercial lines business, primarily focused on churches, non-profits, and faith-based organizations.
  • Handle Certificates of Insurance (COIs), policy change requests, vehicle additions, account renewals, and Acord submissions as required.
  • Collaborate with producers who handle on-the-ground client interactions, while managing back-office servicing tasks.
  • Utilize Applied Epic to process and manage workflows efficiently.
  • Provide occasional training and guidance to team members on Epic and best practices.
  • Contribute to a team-oriented approach to servicing accounts, ensuring smooth workflow and communication.

Qualifications/Requirements

  • Experience:
    • Extensive experience in commercial lines insurance, with a focus on servicing churches, non-profits, and faith-based organizations.
    • Applied Epic experience is mandatory.
    • Erie Insurance experience is a significant plus.
    • Non-profit insurance experience is highly desirable.
  • Skills:
    • Strong organizational and multitasking abilities.
    • Excellent communication and interpersonal skills, with the ability to foster collaboration within the team.
    • Proficiency in handling COIs, policy changes, renewals, and Acord submissions.
  • Location:
    • Preference for candidates within 45 minutes of Harrisburg/Mechanicsburg, PA.
    • Hybrid work arrangement (2-3 days in-office) preferred, but fully remote candidates will be considered if highly qualified.
  • Other:
    • Comfortable working with faith-based organizations, though a personal faith background is not required.
    • Willingness to participate in a virtual interview followed by an in-person meeting.

#LI-CS1