Job title: CSR/ Junior Producer
Job type: Permanent
Emp type: Full-time
Industry: Insurance
Functional Expertise: Producer
Location: Wellington, OH
Job published: 06/04/2026
Job ID: 155540

Job Description

CSR / Junior Producer Hybrid

Job Summary

Seeking a dedicated and adaptable Customer Service Representative (CSR) / Junior Producer Hybrid to join a growing team. This role offers a unique opportunity to work in a collaborative, family-oriented environment where you can wear many hats and contribute to the success of a thriving insurance agency. If you are passionate about providing exceptional service, managing diverse accounts, and contributing to a supportive team culture, we encourage you to apply.

Compensation Package

  • New Haven Location: Base salary up to $50,000 + commissions on new business (2% of agency premium, paid one time).
  • Wellington Location: Base salary up to $55,000 (absolute cap; $40,000–$50,000 preferred) + commissions on new business (2% of agency premium, paid one time).
  • Competitive benefits package, paid time off, professional development opportunities, etc.

Responsibilities

  • New Haven Location:
    • Serve as a generalist CSR, managing a variety of tasks including reviewing and writing new business.
    • Handle a round-robin workflow and address day-to-day needs as they arise.
    • Manage a book of business with a premium size of $3.2 million.
  • Wellington Location:
    • Perform CSR duties with additional producer responsibilities.
    • Manage a book of business with a premium size of $2.7 million.
    • Work closely with a senior producer and adapt to a structured yet dynamic environment.
  • Handle personal lines, commercial lines, and farm accounts.
  • Communicate effectively with clients, carriers, and team members.
  • Utilize the EPIC agency management system to manage accounts and workflows.

Qualifications/Requirements

  • Licenses/Certifications: Property & Casualty (P&C) license required.
  • Experience:
    • New Haven: Open to candidates with less than 5 years of experience; early-career professionals are encouraged to apply.
    • Wellington: Preference for more experienced candidates who can work effectively in a demanding environment.
  • Technical Skills:
    • Familiarity with the EPIC agency management system is preferred but not required.
    • Experience with Hawksoft or similar systems is acceptable.
  • Soft Skills:
    • Strong communication skills, including the ability to engage in meaningful conversations with clients and team members.
    • Adaptability and a willingness to take on varied responsibilities.
    • Self-starter with a growth mindset and a proactive approach to problem-solving.
    • Strong organizational skills to manage workflow volume effectively.

#LI-CM1

Apply with indeed
File types (doc, docx, pdf, rtf, png, jpeg, jpg, bmp, jng, ppt, pptx, csv, gif) size up to 5MB